History, Restapled - Lands, Ho; Prices, Low
Welcome back for another History, Restapled, a Commander-focused column that attempts to validate a newer card’s status as a staple by looking at how cards that are similar, synergistic, or competing have fared in the past financially.
It’s not often these columns will contain 10 staples, but
The Shire , Barad-dur , Minas Tirith , Mines of Moria , and Rivendell
Commander decks are large, but once you fill slots for card draw, ramp, removal/interaction, and protection, there’s little room for cards that don’t actively contribute to the game plan. Therefore, one of the best ways to expand the reach of your deck is to run lands with additional abilities beyond tapping for mana. Plenty leap to mind, but the ones that enter untapped are generally more expensive and in higher demand.
The Channel lands from
The core Tales of Middle-earth set contains its own cycle of legendary lands, each with consequential abilities and, in a format defined by legendary creatures, requiring minimal setup to enter untapped. My favorite is Mines of Moria because it’s great at breaking stalled board states later in the game when graveyards are populated, commanders are likely on the field, mana advantages are narrow, and end-of-turn, instant speed effects enable players to hold up mana without sacrificing tempo. It has a high ceiling, sure, but the floor is relatively high, as well: a Mountain that occasionally enters tapped. Best of all, both versions of the card cost less than one dollar.
Minas Tirith is the priciest of the bunch at $4 but draws you cards simply for attacking and functions most of the time as a Plains. The worst one, objectively, is The Shire, because, besides merely making a Food token, it reduces the Forest count for a color that often relies on fetching Forests or maintaining a high number of Forests in play. But gaining life is underrated in Commander and, at minimum, The Shire produces a permanent that’s also an artifact, which can enhance quite a lot of synergistic elements—something a basic Forest will never be able to do.
In previous columns, I’ve speculated on the likelihood that a card from Tales of Middle-earth will be reprinted in a non-Tolkien set, and some folks have expressed optimism that the more ambiguously named ones might qualify. However, all five of the above are tied to specific locations in Middle-earth, so I’d say the chances of a reprint outside of this universe are quite low. Grab them while you can.
The Shire | ||
Barad-dur | ||
Minas Tirith | ||
Mines of Moria | ||
Rivendell |
STATUS: Staples that should not be forgotten or lost
Commander Masters
The most premium of non-premium sets contains quite a number of reprints that drive down the prices of some powerful staples. Here are a few from Commander Masters worth picking up:
Ohran Frostfang
For one more mana than
Grasp of Fate
This three-for-one white staple debuted at $3.50 in late 2015 and never sank anywhere near that price again. The reprint, at $3, finally makes it possible for your wallet to revisit those halcyon days.
Song of the Dryads
Here’s a removal spell from
Ugin, the Ineffable
While this powerful planeswalker has spent most of its time below $5, the reprint sets the price at $1, unlocking the card for even the tightest of budgets. I love Ugin, the Ineffable in mono-color decks, particularly red, black, and blue ones that struggle with certain types of permanents once they’re on the field. The static ability ranges from flavor text to a free
Alms Collector
Power creep has not been kind to this Cat Cleric, yet the card remained north of $10 since mid-2020. Post-Commander Masters, Alms Collector is a bulk rare—not bad for white card draw with light stax upside. I wish it was slightly stronger against
Ohran Frostfang | ||
Grasp of Fate | ||
Song of the Dryads | ||
Ugin, the Ineffable | ||
Alms Collector |
STATUS: Stable staples, grab when able
Perfect 10
I’d love to know which Commander Masters reprints you’re most excited to grab, especially if it’s a card you’ve had your eye on for some time that never quite fit into your budget. Similarly, I’d be curious to know more evidence from the field regarding how often the Tales of Middle-earth legendary lands enter untapped. This column is always going to be evolving and I hope the community can assist with that process for the betterment of us all. Send me a note on Twitter or via Reddit and let’s staple like we mean it!
Check out these articles:
A Penny Saved, An Exchange Earned by Ryan Cole
Dinos and Merfolk and Pirates, Oh My! (Also Vampires) by Adam Berg
Modern Times - Pro Tour: LOTR by Corey Williams
Steve Heisler is a writer and pop culture journalist covering comedy, games, television, film and the tech industry. His work has been published in Rolling Stone, GQ, Variety, The AV Club, Fast Company and the Chicago Sun-Times. He began collecting Magic cards during Fourth Edition and plays Commander and Modern primarily. He also enjoys tennis, the Dark Souls family of video games and supporting live comedy. He lives in Chicago with his cat, Rosie.